In whistle collecting so much can be seen in the different parts — even the mouthpieces. Take for example the mouthpiece on a general service whistle. You might say that they all look alike, but ARE they all alike ???
No. Each manufacturer used different molds, tools and style. In reality each would be a reflection of the individual as much as personality.
Consider the Knoxall GSW that is up for auction on eBay right now ( the Google of on line auctions ) It is being sold as being made by John Barrall manufacturer. Why ?? Because the seller uses a book and follows it rather than following the Manufacturer.
There are two types of cast mouthpieces that DOWLER made. The second was made circa 1890 to 1900. It is slightly longer than most cast mouthpieces and curved in wards, not rounded outwards and short — ( distinctive to Dowler ) just abruptly finishing it’s curve at the opening. It is very distinctive. However Barrall never did this.
Barrall is not stamped on the whistle, but neither is Dowler. It turns out that Barrall never even made a Knoxall Police call or general service whistle.
What’s the point ?? You can become adept at this hobby and tell a lot more about your whistles with research !!!
Users This Month : 620
Total views : 147728